Cayuga Mutual Insurance Company

Our mission is to provide the best possible insurance products and services. We are a community based, financially stable company providing our policyholders owners with peace of mind since 1875. When you are insured with a Mutual, you're protected by the best! Among the most financially secure insurance networks in the world...and its owned by policyholders! Collectively the system is one of the largest property insurers in Ontario. Through their own guarantee fund and reinsurance plan each mutual is backed by every mutual in the system. Mutual means...you are the owner...you have a say in how the system is run. 100% Canadian and owned by policyholders. No profits paid to outside shareholders. Protected by Farm Mutual Reinsurance Plan, Fire Mutual Guarantee Fund and 50 other mutuals. Locally Owned and operated with directors elected from community. Neighbour Helping Neighbour